疑難雜症萬事通
在網路上遇到任何問題都可以在這邊找找看唷

Search

關於 5th amendment ，我們在網路上蒐集到這些相關的討論、資訊與評價

相關標籤 相關照片 相關影片
在5th amendment這個產品中，有4篇Facebook貼文，粉絲數超過14萬的網紅Campus TV, HKUSU 香港大學學生會校園電視，也在其Facebook貼文中提到， 【現場直播｜Live】 二零二一年度第五次評議會緊急會議｜The 5th Ordinary Ordinary Council Meeting, Session 2021 Date: 28th June 2021 (Monday) Time: 19:00 – Venue: Union Counci...

5th amendment 在 Campus TV, HKUSU 香港大學學生會校園電視 Facebook 的最佳貼文

Campus TV, HKUSU 香港大學學生會校園電視 By Campus TV, HKUSU 香港大學學生會校園電視

2021-06-28 19:00:47 有 8 人按讚
  • Share this:

【現場直播｜Live】 二零二一年度第五次評議會緊急會議｜The 5th Ordinary Ordinary Council Meeting, Session 2021

Date: 28th June 2021 (Monday)

Time: 19:00 –
Venue: Union Council Chamber UG201, Union Building

Link: https://youtu.be/tEOa5vtKlS8

Section A
1. To read out the correspondences
2. To receive maiden speeches of new Council members
3. To report the motions carried by circulation
4. To receive and adopt the agenda
5. To receive and adopt the minutes of previous Meetings

Section B
1. Questions put to the Union Executives, other Councillors, other Official Observers,
Council Committees, or Union sub-organisations
2. To receive annual reports of Council Standing Committees, Session 2020
a. Union Finance Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
b. Union Election Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
3. To receive annual reports of Union Executives, Session 2020
a. President
b. Financial Secretary
c. President of Sports Association
4. To receive the report of Council Committees ad hoc
a. Orientation Affairs Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
b. Tendering Committee of Notebook Ownership Program 2020, HKUSU Council,
Session 2020
c. Annual Election Commission 2021, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
5. To discuss amendment to the Internal Regulation of HKUSU
6. To discuss amendment to the Financial Regulation of HKUSU
7. To discuss matters related to the Electoral Subsidy of Union By-election 2021
8. To receive and adopt the Union Budget, Session 2021
9. To Enact the Orientation Regulation 2021
10. To enact the Orientation Arbitration Regulation 2021
11. To endorse statements issued by Council Committees
12. Any Other Business

Tags:
Campus TV, HKUSU 香港大學學生會校園電視

About author
This is the permanent facebook page of Campus TV, HKUSU. Like this page to subscribe to our programmes! www.campustv.com.hk www.youtube.com/hkucampustv
本頁為香港大學學生會校園電視面書專頁。 This is the official page of the Campus TV, HKUSU. Like this page to subscribe to our programmes! www.youtube.com/hkucampustv
139656 followers 113099 likes "http://www.campustv.com.hk/"
View all posts

5th amendment 在 麻利 malisheep Facebook 的最佳解答

麻利 malisheep By 麻利 malisheep

2019-06-20 13:05:42 有 57 人按讚
  • Share this:


《免於恐懼的自由祈禱會》
呂秉權先生的分享

#絕望中的希望 《免於恐懼的自由》祈禱會
呂秉權 兄弟分享--- #沸點即場筆錄

片段 ▶️ https://www.facebook.com/109180535767655/posts/2493494547336230?s=548400948&v=e&sfns=mo

主教、神父、各位兄弟姊妹，大家好！很感恩可以在這裏跟大家分享，大家還是平平安安。我想起一位從大陸偷偷地來香港返教會，「宗教自由行」的姊妹，她說，想不到竟然可以在街頭報佳音，如果在大陸做這事的話，一早就被拒捕了！原來，我們可以站在街上祈禱、唱聖詩，是這麼美好的事情！

今次逃犯條例的修訂，令政府有一個很大的讓步，我可以說，這是一個奇蹟、是一個神蹟！

為我們這群，一直研究中國大陸政治的朋友來說，看著所有原先的蛛絲馬跡，中央對港的方針，是沒有讓步這計劃的！我跟大家說，原本這樣的逃犯條例，是怎樣的一回事：北京和林鄭月娥，他們以為這條例必定順利通過！為什麼？

首先，立法會絕對有足夠的票數去支持、商界也在中央的操控下一一「跪低」，即使你不情願，你不願意收回你的司法覆核也好，你最好也要跪低。

第二，在民意而言，北京已經評估過香港狀況，就算最多反對聲音、最壞程度，北京原先的評估，反對者就是佔中的規模；而佔中的規模，特區政府和警方已綽綽有餘，足以瓦解這行動於無形。兼且，這幾年來，香港的警隊， 已經不再是同樣的警隊了！香港的警隊已經進化了很多。

在後勤，我們亦知道解放軍已預備好。上一次佔領行動的時候，解放軍駐港部隊的深圳後勤部隊已經演練了；他們以四人枱一個人的規模，預備進行必要的介入，但最終沒有用到，但是他們是有部署的。如果有1萬人的集會，四個人抬1人，換句話說，就是說有4萬兵力在後勤準備。今次，不要以為我們看不見明顯的徵兆；解放軍駐港部隊已經不經不覺地做了不少工作。大家可記得？山竹襲港時，市面和郊野公園有大片破壞，解放軍駐港部隊幾百人，居然越過了駐軍法，沒有通知特區政府的情況下，可以出兵幾百人，穿着制服，他們以清理郊區的名義，動員幾百人，沒有駐軍令、沒有適當程序，他們就派了幾百個解放軍來了。這一點，我自己認為是十分危險的訊號。

第三，除了因為林鄭信心爆棚外，還有中央的因素在內。如果我們只看表面的話，會以為（修例）只是林鄭個人決定。其實，逃犯條例的修訂，中央跟香港談了很多年了，他們問香港要人，要了很多年了！今次在這修訂逃犯條例的大背景下，中央政府希望「法律武器化」香港；簡單來說，就是用任何香港的程序和法律去實行國家安全，這至高無上的保障。中央想通過這條移交逃犯條例，其實是一條「萬能Key」，文匯大公的權威解讀，國內中港智囊研究多年中港移交條例，除了一般所說：大陸犯罪的人匿藏在香港、除了香港人在國內犯罪回到香港外...... 更重要的計劃，就是威脅「國家安全」的罪犯。

在文匯大公報，5月23日引用權威人士解讀：當遇到威脅國家安全的罪犯時，一般是由香港，按照香港法律程序去處理的。那換句話說，是有不一般的情況了？當不一般的情況出現了，是不是就是可以超越香港程序去處理？而在國內研究這問題的智囊，很清楚跟我們說，在中國法律上，是沒有「政治犯」的！我們從前說反革命罪犯、或現在煽動顛覆國家政權罪犯，他們並非「政治犯」，而只是三個字：刑事犯！當我們面對刑事犯的時候，是否不引渡呢？是不是用政治犯為保護罩，我們就不引渡危害國家安全的罪犯呢？國內的智囊說，國內的邏輯是相反的！正是這些人破壞國家安全，香港更不能夠成為國家安全的漏洞，更加要去移交（罪犯），這是最恐怖的。

為什麼我們覺得恐怖呢？因為我們怎樣去定義一個人危害國家安全呢？那標準是相當之闊！在內地，只要你所謂「得罪共產黨」，你做一些黨不喜歡你做的事；你批評中央、你去支援內地的宗教，也許你報導一些新聞，內地不喜歡的......很容易你就會被檢控。

以往很多人被「砌生豬肉」（誣告），用藏毒罪、用偷竊罪、用間諜罪...... 被指控，是很恐怖的情況！我們中國大陸所行的體制，是人民民主專政，簡單來說就是「專政」兩個字！

專政是什麼呢？專政就是說，當面對政府所認為的「敵人」時，就可以不需要依照法律辦事、可以越過法律。如果大家還記得，在內地發生過不少專政事件，劉霞為什麼會完全沒有在法律程序下，被剝奪人身自由、被軟禁這麼久？銅鑼灣書店的相關人士，為什麼可以在香港跟泰國等地被綁架；被綁了之後，自願被剝奪所有法律權利，不見家人，在電視機面前認罪......為什麼呢？因為當時中國政府正在實行專政。

國家主席劉少奇，用憲法的名義叫大家不可以這樣去迫死人， 到最後......他們將一個被鬥到遍體鱗傷，急需醫院治療的一個國家主席，丟在河南的一個密室，失救至死。專政還可以令十大元帥賀龍，他患有糖尿病和各種疾病；死的時候被人專政，把高質量的葡萄糖液，打進他的身體，葡萄糖液與糖尿病結合...... 令他的腎臟衰竭、身體衰竭而死。

當一個國家說自己依法治國，但隨時可以行專政的時候，香港的法律開了一扇門，與這種專政的做法接連、以國家安全名義...... 這是多麼恐怖的事呢？而這個程序去修例，就是原來的劇本！

原來的劇本亦包括，中央在年頭的時候，審視全國的形勢，去防止各種的失控，各種不穩定因素，各種的風險。國家開了全國最高省部級的領導幹部大會，有習近平在中央黨校開講，很出名的什麼灰犀牛、黑天鵝、六個穩定，就是從這會議中出來的。當時中共領導人，是很害怕一件事： 所謂的中國「逢九必亂」，逢年份有9，他們就容易有大亂，中共見證着：
1949年，國共的更替；59年，大饑荒；69年，中蘇珍寶島之戰，國家主席劉少奇被鬥死；79年，中越戰爭；89年，六四事件；99年，法輪功圍中南海；2009年，新疆七五騷亂。

2019年頭的時候，中共已經開了全國大會去防止有任何混亂的情況。他們做了很多措施，亦都分享了很多經驗怎去處理問題。當時在中央的劇本中，香港的局勢可以說：穩如泰山！沒有可能在逢九必亂的其中一亂，是沒有可能的。他們所擔心的是經濟、與及萬一出現的失業問題，中美貿易之戰，絕對不是香港的事情。

近年，中央領隊領導人對香港的研判，他們認為香港局勢是非常的大好！為什麼這樣說呢？因為全面管治權已逐步落實，立法會受到建制的加持，由於這些社運、甚至旺角騷亂的人，相繼被重判；各種不同政見的人被DQ，整個社會的公民意識越來越低；北京與林鄭政府是極有信心的，這條例，不可能不通過！習近平早年說怎樣處理群眾運動時，清楚地說到：他剛剛上台，要扭轉胡、溫時代的那種妥協作風。習近平說：不可以：小鬧小解決、大鬧大解決、不鬧不解決！他不能讓這情況持續下去！習近平任內對港的多番措施，沒有一件證明他是妥協的；除了梁振英的不連任，而當時，是因為他在建制及商界中拿不到票 。有數票的人說，取得601票已是十分困難了，不是群眾的力量造成。而今次面對6月9日103萬人大遊行，大家可以看到，林鄭與北京政府當時的不妥協，遊行完後，無論人數有多少，依然故我，條例繼續。

當我們常常會問：天主你在哪裏？天主，為什麼香港可以被人摧殘至此？不知怎樣來了一個逆轉 ！當我們很多時質疑青年是「廢青」，在612星期三，出現了一個大家都不想看見、但卻成了一個逆轉的場面！一班青年人，他們有些是寫了遺書的，決定自己去擋子彈的情況下，他們去衝擊立法會、衝擊警方防線！當然從法律來說，他們的做法是犯法的；但是從一個公義的角度，他們認為這事情不應該這樣繼續下去，所以，他們做了抗爭。而這種抗爭，竟令到已經升級變形的香港警隊，殺紅了眼，連內部評估，也認為當警方被衝擊後，出去對群眾的清場用槍、去射頭部、用各種武器去攻擊一些無辜的人；警隊的一些內部評估，也認為是過火了。是這情況令到整件事逆轉！整個國際的壓力，令到北京政府難以承受。

那原先他們的計劃是怎樣呢？在內地的電視，和平集會的鏡頭全部被刪去，被描繪成示威者衝擊警察、暴徒般襲擊，今次他們想說成香港暴徒襲擊政府，以拿取道德高地。殊不知，警方濫用武器、過度執法、逆轉了整個畫面！原本習近平的計劃：叫做「楓橋經驗」，那就是遇到群眾事件時，就地解決，矛盾不上交！煎你的皮、但內裡燒不焦；鬥你的表面，但內部不會出事......

但很可惜，今次特區政府不單止沒有「矛盾不上交」，不但上交中央、還上了國際層面；令中共面對非常大的壓力，因而出現了一個逆轉。

我認為，這是天主的眷顧、天主的神跡！

到最後，我想用一個眼神去完結我這個分享：我記得，在612過後，我跟朋友去了一所聖堂，在聖堂門口見到一對警察，虎視眈眈，還是非常強硬的態度，他們想去捉拿聖堂內的青年。我在聖堂內看見一位青年，穿著黑背心，眼神很惶恐。我問他，可要幫他買件衣服，讓他離開？他說：「不用了」，他在聖堂得到了保護，找到了他的家，真正的父親、母親。當我行出教堂外，警察的目光，好像張牙舞爪，想要抓一個孩子......

希望上主繼續眷顧我們，賜我們平安；希望傷者能得平安...... 主佑香港！

2019年6月19日晚上

▶️ 祈禱會直播 https://www.facebook.com/1764198537146061/posts/2394608974105011?s=548400948&sfns=mo

▶️再談逃犯條例修定研討會 https://www.facebook.com/hkjpcom/videos/2180158835373248?s=667412853

“Hope in despair”
sharing of Mr Lui Ping Kuen at the “freedom from fear” prayer meeting

Bishop, father, brothers and sisters:

I am so grateful to share with you all here and I am grateful that we are all safe. I think of a sister who sneaked in Hong Kong to attend church services, “Religious Individual Visit”. She was surprised that there was street caroling in Hong Kong because one will be arrested if one does this in the Mainland. It is so wonderful that we can pray and sing hymns on the street!

I can claim that it is a miracle that the government retreats on the extradition bill!

For people like us who have studied Chinese Politics for a long time, we found that the Central Government had no plan to retreat in their policy towards Hong Kong from the clues we observed. I told you what the extradition bill was about originally: Beijing and Carrie Lam thought that the bill must be passed smoothly! Why?

First of all, there were definitely enough votes in the Legislative Council to pass the bill, and the business sector also submitted under the control of the Central Government, whether you were willing or not, whether you wanted to withdraw the judicial review application or not, you’d better submit to it.

Secondly, the Central Government has assessed the views of people in Hong Kong and they thought that the worst case scenario would be similar to that of the scale of Umbrella Movement only. They believed that the HKSAR Government and the Police could handle that scale of protest easily. Moreover, Hong Kong Police Force is not the same as the one a few years ago and has improved a lot. We also knew that the People's Liberation Army was well prepared to support. The logistic unit of People's Liberation Army Hong Kong Garrison in Shenzhen has drilled during the previous occupying movement. They prepared to intervene, on a scale of 4 soldiers to remove 1 protester, when necessary. Although it was not carried out eventually, they were prepared. If there is a rally of 10 thousands people, 4 soldiers removing 1 protester, that means there are 40 thousands soldiers preparing to support. We can see significant signs that People's Liberation Army Hong Kong Garrison has done a lot when we are not aware of it. Do you still member, there was extensive damage in urban and rural areas during the strike of severe typhoon Mangkhut? A few hundred soldiers from the People's Liberation Army Hong Kong Garrison wearing their uniform, bypassing the Garrison Law and without informing the HKSAR Government, were mobilised in the name of clearing the rural areas. Ignoring the Garrison Law and proper procedure, they sent a few hundred soldiers. I think this is a very dangerous sign.

Thirdly, besides the overconfidence of Carrie Lam, the Central Government is also a key factor. On the surface, we would think this (amendment of the bill) is solely Carrie Lam’s own decision. In fact, the amendment of extradition bill has been discussed between the Central Government and the HKSAR Government for many years. They have been asking Hong Kong for people they wanted for many years! The Central Government wants to make law their weapon in Hong Kong, to put it simply, the Central Government wants to exercise national security by using any procedures and laws in Hong Kong, this is the ultimate protection. The Central Government wants to pass this extradition bill, which works for nearly anything. From the authoritative interpretation by the Wen Wei Po and Ta Kung Pao, the think tank in Mainland which has been studying extradition law between Mainland and Hong Kong for many years, that it is because, besides the situations that the criminals from the Mainland hide in Hong Kong or Hong Kong people committed offences in the Mainland and hide in Hong Kong, more importantly the criminals that threaten “national security”.

On 23 May, Wen Wei Po and Ta Kung Pao quoted interpretation from authority that it is normally handled by Hong Kong according to Hong Kong legal procedures when there are criminals that threaten national security. In other words, there are abnormal situations? Will it bypass the Hong Kong legal procedures to handle the case when abnormal situation occurs? Member of think tank in the Mainland who studies this issue told us clearly that, there is no “political offenders” under Chinese law. No matter the “counter-revolutionary” offenders in the past or the current “inciting subversion of state power” offenders, they are not “political offenders” but criminal offenders! Are we not to extradite a criminal offender? Are we not to extradite offenders threatening national security by using “political offender” as a protection shield? Member of think tank in the Mainland said, the logic in Mainland is the opposite! As these people cause damage to national security, Hong Kong should not be the loophole of national security and more justified to extradite (offenders). This is the most dangerous part.

Why do we think that this is dangerous? It is because it is very easy for one to be defined as threatening national security. In the Mainland, if you do anything that the Communist Party doesn’t want you to do and upset the Communist Party, such as criticising the Central Government, supporting the religions in Mainland, reporting some news they don’t like. You are easy to be prosecuted.

In the past, there were a lot of people being prosecuted with false accusations including possession of drugs, theft, espionage. It is very horrible! The system in Mainland China is called “People’s democratic dictatorship”, to put it simply, dictatorship! What is dictatorship? It means that the Government do not need to follow the law and can bypass the law when dealing with their “enemies”. There were many incidents occurred under dictatorship in the Mainland if you still remember. Why were Liu Xia put under house arrest, deprived of personal freedom, for such a long time without following any legal procedures? Why were the people related to Causeway Bay Books kidnapped in places like Hong Kong and Thailand, then voluntarily deprived all legal rights, not to meet their families, and pleaded guilty on television? Why? It is because the Chinese Government is practising dictatorship at that time.

President Liu Shaoqi asked people not to persecute and caused the death of others in the name of constitution, at the end… They left a president who was seriously hurt by the crowd and was required to be sent to hospital for treatment urgently, in a room in Henan secretly and died as he was not saved in time. Dictatorship also made one of the then 10 Marshals of the Communist Party, He Lung, who suffered from diabetes and other illnesses, dead after an injection of a large dose of glucose. The glucose and diabetes caused his death by kidney failure and multiple organ failure.

When a country claims that it exercises rule by law, but it can also exercise dictatorship at anytime, if the Hong Kong legal system will be connected to this dictatorship, in the name of national security… how horrible is this? And this is the original script, which the law would be amended according to this procedure! The original script also included that, the Central Government has assessed the situation of the whole country to prevent any out-of-control situation, to prevent any uncertainties and risks in the beginning of this year. A countrywide meeting for officials of provincial level was held and Xi Jinping gave a speech at the Central Party School. Those famous saying included “grey rhinocero”, “black swan”, “six certainties” are originated from this meeting. The leaders of Communist Party were scared of one thing: the so-called “chaos in the years ending in 9” as the Communist Party witnessed chaos happened in those years ending in 9: 1949 - the Kuomintang was replaced by the Communist; 1959 - the Great Famine; 1969 - Sino-Russian Zhenbao dao War and President Liu Shaoqi was dead; 1979 - Sino-Vietnamese War; 1989 - Tiananmen Square Protests; 1999 - Falun Gong practitioners surrounded the Zhongnanhai (Central Government compound in Beijing); 2009 - 5th July Incident in Xinjiang.

In the beginning of 2019, countrywide meeting was held by the Communist Party to prevent any chaotic situation. They have done a lot and shared experience on handling problems. On the script of the Central Government at that time, the situation in Hong Kong was extremely stable. This was impossible for Hong Kong to become one of the chaos in the “chaos in the years ending in 9”. This was impossible. They were worried about the economics and the possible unemployment problem, US-China Trade War, definitely not Hong Kong issue.

The leaders of Central Government assessed that the circumstance in Hong Kong was very favourable in recent years. Why did they think so? It is because overall jurisdiction is gradually exercising in Hong Kong, the Legislative Council is supported by the pro-establishment camp; the social activists or even people involved in MongKok Riot were serving severe sentences; people of different political views were disqualified, civil awareness of the community became lower and lower; Beijing and Carrie Lam’s team were very confident in passing the bill. Talking about how to handle social movement, Xi Jinping stated that he would change the compromising style of Hu(Jintao)-Wen(Jiabao) Era when he came to power. Xi Jinping said no to “small conflict solves on a small scale, large conflict solves on a large scale, no conflict then nothing will be solved”! He could not allow this situation to continue. None of the policies towards Hong Kong showed any compromise during Xi Jinping’s rule, except no second term of office for CY Leung. It was because he could not get enough votes from the pro-establishment camp and the business sector at that time. One who counted the number of votes (before the election to estimate the number) said that it was difficult enough to get 601 votes. It was not a result of the power of the people. There were 1 million and 30 thousands people joining the demonstration on 9th June, we could see that Carrie Lam and Beijing Government did not compromise. No matter how many people joined the demonstration, they continued the procedures to pass the bill after the demonstration.

When we keep asking: “Where are you God?” “God, why are Hong Kong people tortured like this?” Here comes a reverse! When we question the youngsters as “useless”, on Wednesday 12th June, a situation that we all didn’t want to see occurred, but it made a reverse! A group of youngsters, some of them have written their testaments and decided to block the bullets, charged against Legislative Council and the Police cordon lines! Of course, their acts were illegal from the legal point of view; however, from the point of justice, they didn’t think that this issue should continue in this way. Therefore, they protested. This kind of protest unexpectedly triggered the uncontrolled attack by the upgraded and distorted Hong Kong Police. Even the internal assessment of the Police Force considered that the Police who used guns, shot in the head and used different weapons to attack innocent people, to clear the scene after being clashed, went too far. This is what made the issue reversed! The international pressure made it unbearable for Beijing Government.

Then what was their original plan? On the Mainland television, shots of peaceful assembly were all deleted and would be described as the protesters crashing the Police and attacking like mob. They wanted to claim that Hong Kong mob attacked the Government to gain moral high ground. However, excessive use of force by the Police reversed the whole situation. The original plan of Xi Jinping was called "Fengqiao Experience” which solves the social events on site and not to escalate it; attacks the surface but not to affect the core part. Unfortunately, the HKSAR Government could not solve the problem on site and escalated to the Central Government, and even reached an international level. It created a very big pressure for the Communist Party and made a reverse.

I think this is mercy from God, a miracle from God!

Lastly, I would like to conclude my sharing by the expression shown in one’s eyes. I remember I went to a church with friends after the 12th June incident and saw a pair of policeman at the entrance of the church, looking aggressive and wanted to catch the youngsters in the church. I saw a youngster in church, wearing a black vest, looked terrified in his eyes. I asked him whether I should help him to get clothes so that he could leave. He answered no. He found protection and home in the church, found his real father and mother. When I left the church, from the look of the policemen, it seemed to me that they wanted to catch a child…

May God continues to bless us with peace and may the wounded be given peace. God bless Hong Kong!

Evening of the 19th of June

#沸點直擊

Tags:
麻利 malisheep

About author
國境之南，太陽之西 赤道上的城，熱帶島中央
63855 followers 50177 likes
View all posts

5th amendment 在 急症狂人 Dr Kwong Facebook 的最讚貼文

急症狂人 Dr Kwong By 急症狂人 Dr Kwong

2018-05-11 18:13:16 有 28 人按讚
  • Share this:


《香港就黎變到連醫院姐姐無拖地都係醫生失德》文長again

呢幾日文科生心情好沉重，在這個醫療資源極度缺乏的香港，醫護人員一次又一次受成為制度下慘痛的犧牲品。

早兩日醫委會對紗布封喉一案下裁決，判處涉事醫生專業失德罪成，停牌六個月，呢個係咪一個合理的判刑，不仿一齊睇睇
==============================
背景資料

病人因咽喉癌而需進行全咽喉切除手術(total laryngectomy)，手術後需要做一個永久造口(permanent laryngectomy stoma)去協助呼吸。

手術後病人被轉移到屬康復醫院的九龍醫院繼續康復的道路。在九龍醫院住院期間護士替病人在造口貼上紗布（這是非常常見的做法去保護造口，但一般不會封實）但在這個個案護士卻封實了造口。
==========================
首先，文科生想講病人傷口護理(wound dressing care)其實是護士的專業。今時今日的護士已不再是三十年前的只跟隨醫生做醫囑派藥照顧病人，而是擁有相當自主的專業，他們現在有學位、有認證、有執照、PRCC、碩士、經驗足夠後更會成為專科護士、資深護士(APN, advance practice nurse)。

醫生在病人護理上完全放心交給護士處理是很合理的事。醫委會的裁決說醫生理應「看實」護士的工作是對護士的侮辱，侮辱了他們的專業自主能力。

醫委會判詞說即使現今醫療系統以團體作為單位，醫生仍有責任去確保所有的護理和輔助醫療無問題。那麼醫委會是否期望醫生在診症、巡房、文書、程序、手術等等工作外仍然要「看實」所有與病人有關的醫療人員包括但不限於護士、物理治療師、職業治療師、言語治療師、營養師、放射治療師、臨床心理學家、病房助理、抽血員？呢個係唔係一個合理期望？現實中在種種制肘下又做唔做到？這種脫離現實環境的判決對醫生是否公道？

如果說在職位上較高級的醫生要就事件負責，那麼該三位涉事護士的上司和病房經理不是一樣要負責嗎？如果無限延伸，那基本上所有接觸過該名病人的醫護人員都要為事件負責。

當一個外科醫生在自己所屬的醫院要做手術、診症、巡房之餘，仍然要去另一間康復醫院巡房而每次要在一日巡幾十個症，但又要被期望可以看實埋理應24小時照顧著病人的護士的工作。這會不會太脫離現實中人類的能力？
=============================
文科生想再一次回應社區組織協會彭先生的觀點。我不知道點解每次有關醫療爭執都會搵彭先生，但我實在不能容忍彭先生一次又一次talk shit

1. 選擇不自己答辯是因為怕被盤問時透露更多錯誤？彭先生除了喜歡代入自己係醫生之外仲代入埋法官的角色。由幾時開始不答辯等於身有屎？彭先生要不要叫美國取消5th amendment，Miranda warning，以後法官要同被告講，你沒有保持沉默的權利，不答辯你就是有罪。唔係每個人都想將自己放係被盤問的position受控方律師的追擊，每個被告都有不答辯的自由。

2. 「但工作量太大並不是犯錯後的求情理由，「照顧病人嘅標準，永遠都唔可以降低」，醫生應對每一個病人盡基本的照顧責任。」

呢個係一個事實，彭先生你接唔接受都好，過量的工作會令犯錯機會增加係常識，你叫個廚師要一個鐘整60碟意粉vs整6碟，個意粉質素都會有分別。唔會因爲醫生係掌握緊病人生命，呢個常識就會突然唔再適用。你可以繼續脫離現實去企係道德高地去「要求」醫生係「不可能的任務」中保持零失誤，但現實話比你聽，不可能的任務不會因為你受訪時企係道德高地輕鬆講兩句就變得可能。

抽離現實，裝清高企係道德高地批評真係好容易，除咗輕鬆咁係傳媒報導中講兩句之外，彭先生你其實做過乜嘢去幫香港崩壞緊的醫療系統，受緊苦的醫護和病人？
=============================
醫學為人類帶來延長生命、改善生活質素的益處，但醫學並非萬能。醫生也是人類的一份子，沒有比其他職業擁有更多的特異功能。醫生可以做的只是在現有環境下盡最大的努力去診治照顧病人。

不切實際地把所有責任都掉到醫生身上只會把香港崩壞中的醫療體系推向燬滅的道路上。

無錯，做得醫生係要有抱負、要有承擔、要有醫德，但市民對醫生的期望都亦必須合理。對醫生抱有抽離現實環境的期望然後話醫生失德，這樣公平嗎？

最後，想引用讀者的一個比喻

「請問有個空姐派飛機餐時唔小心燙傷個客, 個客係社交媒體開晒名小個空姐同你（機師）, 重點係之後你都要比人罰停職因為你冇睇好你個空姐派餐, 你覺得公唔公平?」

香港的醫療環境愈來愈惡劣，文科生很感激仍然留在香港公立醫療系統服務的醫護人員。

Reference
Apple daily Facebook page

Tags:
急症狂人 Dr Kwong

About author
香港土生土長，自稱「醫學界陳展鵬」嘅急症專科醫生。係公立縱橫十幾載，見盡生死，冤婦，廢老，廢青，無賴，呃病假嘅人生百態。快要爆炸是我像狂人，永不滅。
41169 followers 36458 likes "http://www.dontcall999.com.hk/"
View all posts
社群媒體上有些相關的討論：
你可能也想看看
5th amendment中文
6th Amendment
Ninth Amendment
Fourteenth Amendment
Eighth Amendment
First Amendment
Fourth Amendment
Second Amendment
搜尋相關連結

#1. US Constitution - Fifth Amendment | Resources

Fifth Amendment Annotated. No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand ...

#2. Fifth Amendment - Grand Jury, Double Jeopardy, Self ...

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising ...

#3. Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution - Wikipedia

The Fifth Amendment protects individuals from being forced to incriminate themselves. Incriminating oneself is defined as exposing oneself (or another person) ...

#4. What Does It Really Mean To “Take the Fifth”? - MoloLamken ...

An individual can only invoke the Fifth Amendment in response to a communication that is compelled, such as through a subpoena or other legal process. · The ...

#5. Fifth Amendment - US Constitution

The Fifth Amendment breaks down into five rights or protections: the right to a jury trial when you're charged with a crime, protection against ...

#6. Fifth Amendment | Summary, Rights, & Facts | Britannica

The Fifth Amendment requires grand jury indictment in prosecutions for major crimes and prohibits double jeopardy for a single offense. It provides that no ...

#7. 5th Amendment US Constitution--Rights of Persons - GovInfo ...

FIFTH AMENDMENT. No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or other- wise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of.

#8. Fifth Amendment Activities | United States Courts

Fifth Amendment Activities. Apply landmark Supreme Court cases to contemporary scenarios related to your rights when you are in police custody.

#9. Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination

A form of privilege, set out in the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution, that gives an individual the right to refuse to answer any questions ...

#10. Fifth amendment Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com

One of the ten amendments to the United States Constitution that make up the Bill of Rights. The Fifth Amendment imposes restrictions on the government's ...

#11. Fifth Amendment (1791) - Annenberg Classroom

To avoid giving government unchecked powers, the Fifth Amendment seeks to provide fair methods for trying people accused of committing a crime.

#12. The Fifth Amendment (video) | Khan Academy

#13. The United States Bill of Rights: First 10 Amendments to

First Amendment Second Amendment Third Amendment Fourth Amendment Fifth Amendment Sixth Amendment Seventh Amendment Eighth Amendment Ninth Amendment

#14. The 5th Amendment and Family Law

This is known as the privilege against self-incrimination, or “pleading the 5th.” The Fifth Amendment privilege extends to statements that would by ...

#15. What Is 5th Amendment Law? - GetLegal

The principles contained in the 5th Amendment are vital to a person accused of a crime. Although the amendment contains several provisions, four elements ...

#16. Your Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination | Nolo

A witness in that situation is relying on the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution, which provides that no person "shall be compelled in any ...

#17. Fifth Amendment definition and meaning - Collins Dictionary

Fifth Amendment definition: an amendment to the US Constitution stating that people may not be compelled to testify... | Meaning, pronunciation ...

#18. Cases - Self-incrimination - Oyez

A case in which the Court was asked to clarify the scope of the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination in a “criminal case”—specifically whether the ...

#19. General Law Fifth Amendment Act 157 of 1993 - South African ...

The General Law Fifth Amendment Act 157 of 1993 intends: to amend the Insolvency Act, 1936, so as to amend the definition of "special mortgage"; ...

#20. 52021XC0201(01) - EN - EUR-Lex

Communication from the Commission Fifth Amendment to the Temporary Framework for State aid measures to support the economy in the current COVID-19 outbreak ...

#21. What is the 5th Amendment? – By a top criminal defense ...

The 5th Amendment addresses criminal procedure and other aspects of the Constitution. ... Like all constitutional amendments, the Fifth Amendment ...

#22. The Fifth Amendment and Takings of Private Property - UMKC ...

This page includes materials relating to the continuing controversy over how the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment should be interpreted.inks, images, ...

#23. THE CONSTITUTION (FIFTH AMENDMENT) ACT, 1955

THE CONSTITUTION (FIFTH AMENDMENT) ACT, 1955 [24th December, 1955.] An Act further to amend the Constitution of India. BE it enacted by Parliament in the ...

#24. Fifth Amendment: Miranda Warning; Eminent Domian & Kelo v ...

The Fifth Amendment: ... “The doctrine that a criminal suspect in police custody must be informed of certain constitutional rights before being ...

#25. Understanding the Fifth Amendment Right to Remain Silent

Although the terms “witness” and “criminal case” naturally evoke visions of a criminal trial, the Supreme Court has long held that the Fifth Amendment applies ...

#26. 10c. Crime and Due Process - USHistory.org

The Constitution, in the 5th and 14th Amendments, declares that the government ... The 5th Amendment protects people from actions of the federal government, ...

#27. Analyzing the 5th Amendment Right Against Self-Incrimination

Students will analyze Ms. Hellman's arguments both for and against invoking her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination and come to a ...

#28. Miranda & the 5th Amendment (MP3) - Federal Law ...

Jenna, how does the Fifth Amendment to our Constitution address police interrogations? Solari: Well Tim, part of the Fifth Amendment says that “no person shall ...

#29. Dr. Rand Paul's FAIR Act Restores Respect for 5th Amendment

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Yesterday, U.S. Senator Rand Paul reintroduced S. 642, the FAIR (Fifth Amendment Integrity Restoration) Act to protect property owners' ...

#30. CPR Perspective: The Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment

The Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution includes a provision known as the Takings Clause, which states that "private property [shall not] be ...

#31. Turnback Asylum Policy Defies 5th Amendment Judge Says

An unwritten Department of Homeland Security "turnback policy" turning away asylum seekers at the U.S.'s southern border violates the Fifth ...

#32. Bill of Rights: Fifth - LibGuides at The Westport Library

The police duty to give these warnings is compelled by the Constitution's Fifth Amendment, which gives a criminal suspect the right to refuse " ...

#33. The Fifth Amendment and Innocent Witnesses - Office of ...

The fifth amendment provides that “no person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.” Ohio v. Reiner (2001) extended the ...

#34. 5th Amendment - The Papers of Justice Tom C. Clark - Tarlton ...

Miranda v. Arizona (1966). On March 13, 1963, police picked up Ernesto Miranda as a suspect in a case of kidnapping and rape. Miranda was placed ...

#35. Why you Need to Actually use the Words – I Take The Fifth

A witness' failure to invoke their Fifth Amendment privilege must be excused where government coercion made the forfeiture of the privilege involuntary. Salinas ...

#36. Privacy & Property Rights | Rights | CONSTITUTION USA with ...

Learn more about these amendments and how they're applied. ... The Fifth Amendment protects the right to private property in two ways.

#37. 5th Amendment - Amazon.com Music

5th Amendment - 5th Amendment - Amazon.com Music. ... 5th Amendment. Sorry, this item is not available in ... 5th Amendment (Artist) Format: Audio CD ...

#38. The Fifth Amendment, Decryption and Biometric Passcodes

A handful of cases have emerged in recent years on the applicability of the Fifth Amendment to demands for passwords to encrypted devices. The ...

#39. What Does the Fifth Amendment Protect? - HG.org

Under the Fifth Amendment, a person cannot be tried or punished twice for the same crime. If a person has already been acquitted of the crime, the prosecution ...

#40. the-fifth-amendment - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and ...

Definition of the-fifth-amendment in Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary. Meaning, pronunciation, picture, example sentences, grammar, usage notes, ...

#41. America's Founding Documents | National Archives

The Bill of Rights is the first 10 amendments to the Constitution. It defines citizens' and states' rights in relation to the Government.

#42. Plead the 5th Rights - Gorelick Law Offices

You have to right to refuse to answer a question if it might incriminate you. Talk to an East Bay criminal defense attorney about your 5th Amendment rights.

#43. Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution - House of ...

The Fifth Amendment (Amendment V) to the United States Constitution is part of the Bill of Rights and protects against abuse of government authority.

#44. 5th Amendment - PUNCH

The onslaught of tourism to Honolulu in the post-War years rapidly diminished the quality of well-wrought cocktails, as bars, in an effort to keep up with.

#45. US Government for Kids: Fifth Amendment - Ducksters

Kids learn about the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution including the grand jury, double jeopardy, taking the fifth, due process, ...

#46. USA Patriot Act and the Attack on the 5th Amendment Right to ...

The article discusses the importance of the right to counsel and why Fifth Amendment protections must apply to citizens and non-citizens alike. The testimony ...

#47. Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination - Boston ...

An experienced criminal defense lawyer can make all the difference in protecting your Fifth Amendment rights and keeping you from potential criminal liability.

#48. The Fifth Amendment - Constitutional Law Reporter

The Fifth Amendment ... Text of Constitution: ... The 'Travis Translation' of Constitution: No one can be made to defend themselves against a crime the government ...

#49. Why the Fifth Amendment Is Much More than 'Pleading the Fifth'

The fifth amendment to the U.S. constitution guarantees many rights for citizens accused of crimes, not the least of which is the protection against ...

#50. What is the 5th Amendment? - Definition, Summary & Court ...

The 5th Amendment defines a person's right to a grand jury, forbids double jeopardy, and protects the right to remain silent.

#51. FIFTH AMENDMENT - US Government Publishing Office

FIFTH AMENDMENT. No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or other- wise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of.

#52. 'Taking the Fifth' in Bankruptcy

Fifth Amendment privilege may be implicated when individuals3 are examined under oath during section 341 meetings of creditors, Bankruptcy Rule 2004 ...

#53. Derek Chauvin invokes 5th Amendment right not to testify

Under the U.S. Constitution's Fifth Amendment, no person "shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be ...

#54. The Fight Over General Flynn, the 5th Amendment and ...

Last week, General Michael T. Flynn invoked his Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination in response to a subpoena duces.

#55. Anti-Tax Law Evasion Schemes - Law and Arguments ... - IRS

Contention: Federal income taxes constitute a "taking" of property without due process of law, violating the Fifth Amendment.

#56. Fifth Amendment | NC Superior Court Judges' Benchbook

Fifth Amendment. Below are Benchbook pages that are tagged with the keyword above. Interrogations. This section discusses the law of interrogation in North ...

#57. "The Prophylactic Fifth Amendment" by Tracey Maclin

Before Miranda was decided, the Court had not squarely confronted the issue of when a violation of the Fifth Amendment occurs. Over fifty years ago, ...

#58. Understanding the Fifth Amendment's Protections - ThoughtCo

The Fifth Amendment: Text, Origins, and Meaning · Protections for People Accused of Crimes · Indictment By a Grand Jury · Double Jeopardy · Self ...

#59. Opinion | Taking the Fifth Too Often - The New York Times

Op-Ed article by Akhil Reed Amar, law professor, says Pres Bush urges strict construction of Constitution, and Fifth Amendment is good place ...

#60. Stafford files U.S. Supreme Court amicus brief on scope of 5th ...

The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees that “no person . . . shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness ...

#61. Fifth Amendment - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics

The Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution prohibits the taking of property without just compensation. What constitutes a taking, under what circumstances, ...

#62. How to Invoke Your Right to Remain Silent - Sammis Law Firm

Those rights include your Fifth Amendment rights against self-incrimination and your Sixth Amendment right to counsel. Don't waive important constitutional ...

#63. Fifth Amendment - Oxford Reference

Fifth Amendment. Quick Reference. One of the ten 'Bill of Rights' amendments (1791) to the United States Constitution, ...

#64. The Fifth Amendment | The National Constitution Center

#65. The Difference between the 5th and 6th Amendment Right to ...

Both the Fifth and Sixth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution involve the right to counsel. While sometimes overlapping, there are several differences ...

#66. Waiving the Fifth Amendment Privileges - LawShelf

Because the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, as interpreted by the Miranda court, is a right that can be waived by the defendant, ...

#67. What is The 5th Amendment? - The Sun

THE Fifth Amendment was part of the Bill of Rights that was added to the Constitution on December 15, 1791. The Fifth Amendment originally only applied to ...

#68. Does 5th Amendment Protect Computer Files From Decryption?

The Fricosu court avoided Fifth Amendment issues by ordering the defendant to produce decrypted versions of her laptop files instead of the ...

#69. The 5th Amendment And SRO Proceedings (Video) - Mondaq

Can the 5th amendment protection be applied in self-regulatory organization (SRO) proceedings? In this week's episode, Mayer Brown partners ...

#70. The Constitution (Fifth Amendment) Act, 1955 - National Portal ...

The Constitution (Fifth Amendment) Act, 1955. [24th December, 1955.] An Act further to amend the Constitution of India.

#71. An Economic Theory of the Fifth Amendment - jstor

The Fifth Amendment's due process clause requires the prosecution to share evidence with the defense, and the right to silence that it guarantees blocks the ...

#72. Woman Invokes 5th Amendment To Avoid Disclosing Laptop ...

SIEGEL: And first, what - if anything - is the established law about encryption and password protections and the Fifth Amendment? Mr. McCULLAGH: ...

#73. Trevor Bauer to invoke the 5th amendment, won't answer ...

Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer intends to invoke his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination and will answer no questions ...

#74. You, Your Phone & Your 5th Amendment Right to Remain Silent

With the fifth amendment in place and your right to remain silent intact, when can the state compel you to produce testimonial evidence from your cellphone?

#75. What Does it Mean to "Plead the Fifth?" - Bird, Stevens ...

The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides that no person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against ...

#76. District Court Applies 5th Amendment to Aliens Outside the U.S.

District Court Applies 5th Amendment to Aliens Outside the U.S.. If ruling stands, the only thing 'expedited removal' would expedite is ...

#77. Flynn to invoke 5th Amendment rights in response to Senate ...

Former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn will invoke his Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination on Monday.

#78. Curbing improper use of the Fifth Amendment - Advocate ...

This article is written from the perspective of a civil defendant asserting his Fifth Amendment privilege, but the analysis is equally valid to address a ...

#79. Flynn to Invoke Fifth Amendment Rights in Response to ...

Former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn plans to invoke his Fifth Amendment in response to congressional subpoena, sources confirm to ...

#80. Congress Is Quietly Abandoning the 5th Amendment - The ...

Scandal Alert: Congress Is Quietly Abandoning the 5th Amendment. Meet the prominent legislators who think it's okay to throw Americans in ...

#81. COA: No 5th Amendment protection for liquidator from order to ...

A liquidating company cannot avoid a court order to produce unredacted documents using the argument that the Fifth Amendment protects them, ...

#82. A Win For The 5th Amendment At The Tax Court - Forbes

The Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination is a cornerstone protection guaranteed by the United States Constitution.

#83. The Fifth Amendment - St Austell Brewery

The Fifth Amendment was brewed by St Austell Brewery Cask Co-ordinator, Bryan Day. Distinctively amber in colour this American style ale uses the finest ...

#84. Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination ... - Lexipol

Court rules Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination from digital evidence is based on foregone conclusion doctrine.

#85. Article 31 of UCMJ similar to Fifth Amendment - Malmstrom Air ...

The Fifth Amendment of the Constitution requires law enforcement to give these warnings when questioning a suspect in custody.

#86. Best Advice to Clinton: Take the 5th Amendment - Los ...

But there is another way of looking at the venerable 5th Amendment. As Chief Justice Earl Warren saw it, the constitutional foundation ...

#87. CONSTITUTION (FIFTH AMENDMENT) ACT, 1976 - pakistani ...

A Court shall have the power to punish a person for contempt of Court in accordance with law". 14. Amendment of Article 206 of the Constitution.

#88. Medical Marijuana, Garrity and the 5th Amendment - OMAG

The 5th Amendment protects individuals against being compelled by the government to incriminate themselves. The Court in Garrity found that ...

#89. Fifth Amendment - Self-Incrimination Lawyers | LegalMatch

The Fifth Amendment of the Constitution reads "no person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself in any criminal case.

#90. Pleading the 5th Amendment in Florida Civil Cases

The Fifth Amendment can be asserted in any proceeding, civil or criminal, administrative or judicial, investigatory or adjudicatory; ...

#91. The Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination

Sarah R. Blumenfeld, The Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination: A New Risk to Witnesses. Facing Foreign Prosecution. United States v.

#92. Bill Cosby to Invoke Fifth Amendment Due to Fear of New

“This is particularly so where numerous states have no criminal statutes of limitations for sex crimes. It is well-settled that the Fifth ...

#93. 5th Amendment: Right to Remain Silent - Arizona Criminal ...

Under the Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution a person shall not be compelled to be witness against themselves in their criminal case.

#94. Fifth Amendment - Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorneys

Adopted in 1791 as part of the Bill of Rights, the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution contains several important clauses that protect people ...

#95. Mental health evaluations and the Fifth Amendment

The Kansas Supreme Court overturned the trial court's decision, ordered a new trial and held that the Fifth Amendment does not prevent a court ...

#96. Fifth Amendment to PREP Act Declaration Expands the Ranks ...

On January 28, 2021, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”) issued a Fifth Amendment to the Declaration under the Public ...

#97. Restoring the 5th Amendment | Congressman Tim Walberg

1895, the Fifth Amendment Integrity Restoration Act (FAIR Act), will raise the level of proof necessary for the federal government to seize ...