【讓法國人傻眼的影集「艾蜜莉在巴黎」–法國網友評論:打破你對巴黎的浪漫幻想🇫🇷】
這禮拜好多學生推薦我看Netflix的新影集:Emily in Paris ,也有許多粉絲「敲碗」,請我介紹這部影集。雖然老早就聽過這部影集了,但在看到法國朋友在網路上的吐槽,我其實對這部片沒有太大的興趣。這兩天,甚至連法國媒體 « Le Parisien »、« Madame le Figaro » 等,都開始轉貼批判 Emily in Paris 的言論。但在許多學生和朋友的熱情推薦下,今天我終於看了第一集。
好不容易決定要打開來看了,沒想到在看影集前,又看到 法國媒體« Ouest France »轉貼法國網友在推特上寫的評論:« Je ris à gorge déployée à chaque plan plus cliché tu meurs de Emily in Paris, je soupçonne que cette série soit faite pour faire rire les Français tellement c’est absurde ! » (每次看 Emily in Paris 我都忍不住笑瘋了,從來沒有看過這麼荒謬的影集。我現在很懷疑這影集根本就是故意用那些老舊的刻板印象來笑死法國人!實在太荒謬了!)各位朋友們,我是真的有打算想看,但總是會有法國的朋友、媒體評論,跳出來阻止我看影集?!真不知道是碰巧,還是命運的安排🤣
所以到底, Emily in Paris踩到了法國人哪個點,惹怒許多地方媒體報導跟網友,讓大家忍不住站出來諷刺這部影集呢?雖然今天只看第一集,但影片中有許多點,完全可以看出美國對法國的刻板印象。今天就來和大家娓娓道來,這些採中法國人的「地雷」有哪些?
簡單介紹這部影片的劇情:女主角是一位年輕的美國女孩Emily,被派到巴黎的行銷公司去上班,故事主軸是敘述她在巴黎新生活中的酸甜苦辣、愛情故事、多采多姿的晚會等等,相信大家聽到這樣的故事劇情,勢必會覺得這是一部「認識巴黎」的影集,也因此受到許多國家的喜愛,但在法國卻引起了不少網友與媒體報導的批評。主要是因為他們不喜歡用不真實的角度介紹巴黎,還有影集中的成千上萬個法式刻板印象,讓法國人完全傻眼。
首先,法國人覺得開場很假,感覺是觀光部會拍的彆扭宣傳片😂
片中女主角從機場搭計程車到市中心會經過好多巴黎的景點、美景等。然而,從巴黎夏爾戴高樂機場,到市中心主要會經過巴黎北邊93省的Seine-Saint-Denis,一個比較複雜的地方,和影集中的畫面根本就是天壤之別。法國網友就寫:« Les Américains qui regardent #EmilyInParis sur Netflix et qui salivent déjà en s'imaginant arriver dans #Paris depuis CDG en taxi ... les pauvres le choc sera terrible. »(看 Emily in Paris 的美國人心裡應該充滿了憧憬,嚮往到巴黎坐計程車的路程。可憐的美國人,他們到時候真的會嚇呆了。)其他網友也分享,為什麼我從機場到市中心的路上,眼前所見的是「骯髒的人行道、被塗鴉的牆壁、被燒掉的車子」,而Emily卻可以看到超美的景色?!
延續「街景」的話題,其實影集中的巴黎街景,是受到最多法國網友最多的批評與諷刺的畫面。有網友驚訝的表示:« Vous vous rendez compte que dans toute la série on n'a pas croisé un seul SDF ???? #EmilyInParis. Ah oui c'est vrai, elle allait au boulot à pied et elle n'a jamais eu à utiliser le métro... D'ailleurs elle n'a croisé aucun pickpocket sur les marches de Montmartre.»
(你們有沒有發現 #EmilyInParis 整個影集一個流浪漢都看不到。再來,女主角走路去上班,不需要搭捷運 …。還有一件事,她逛了蒙馬特的時候,怎麼都沒有遇到扒手呢?)
巴黎人的通勤時間是全法國最長,因為房子很難找,又很貴,常常需要坐很久的捷運,用走路的方式到辦公室是一種奢侈。許多女網友也注意到,巴黎的街頭很多是用鵝卵石鋪路,女主角走路去上班還可以穿高跟鞋,真的很奇妙。因為這些細節,法國人看的時候都覺得很假。
除了不切實際的街景,片中有許多文化議題,也不像現代法國主流的文化樣貌,比較像是美國眼中的法式刻板印象。就有一位網友表示:« Personne n'a informé les scénaristes que personne ne fume plus dans les bureaux en France et qu'un PDG ne fait jamais la bise à un étranger qui débarque travailler chez lui ?... Ridicules ces clichés »
(怎麼沒有人通知寫影集腳本的人,現在法國已經好久沒有人在辦公室抽煙呢?再來,主管不會跟新來的員工碰臉頰打招呼,更何況是對外國人!這些刻板印象有夠荒謬!)
另外一個引起網友熱烈討論的畫面:Emily 在巴黎租的房子,在影集中被稱為 « une chambre de bonne »「傭人房」。但現實生活中的「傭人房」,其實會比影集中的房間再小兩到三倍。法國網友就忍不住諷刺:« Je bloque sur #EmilyInParis. Elle gagne combien ? Parce qu’un appart de 30m2, des achats chez Chanel et la note de pressing qu’elle doit se fader, on est a plus de trois SMIC tranquille. Ça a changé les salaires de junior en marketing. »
(我在還在想 #EmilyInParis 到底月薪賺多少呢?房子這麼大,都去Chanel買奢侈品,還可以把衣服送洗。他的薪資最少領三分 SMIC(大約15萬台幣)。行銷公司新來菜鳥的薪水真的變很多欸。)
大家都說魔鬼藏在細節裡面,這麼不符合現實的細節讓很多法國觀眾看不下去。甚至連背景音樂也是一大問題,一位網友說:« 5 min du premier épisode, déjà 2 chansons "françaises" jamais entendues et clairement pas chantées par des Français avec tous les mots de politesse possibles, ça me saoule déjà »(看了前五分鐘,已經出現了兩首所謂的法文歌,法國人都沒聽過的歌,歌手的法文也不標準,歌詞很怪,這影集我已經看煩了!)
影集中有太多文化不正確,甚至是刻板印象的問題,我在今天的文章真的說不完。不過,法國人的民族性「愛批評」,其實也是法國文化很重要的一塊,他們認為批評是一種交流,批評才能讓人進步,因為希望喜歡的人或事情能進步,我們就得批評。法國人特別愛批評的這個文化,我想不只有法國,在國際媒體報導的時候都會有類似的反應。我當時還在義大利唸書的時候,只要到外面走一步我就會很興奮,想著:「哇!被義大利充滿了歷史的建築物和浪漫的街景完全征服了。」那時候的義大利室友都無法理解我對於他們國家的心動,他們也只注意人行道不乾淨、遊客太多、物價一直在漲等,住久了也開始無法珍惜現在的生活像住在「藝術作品」一樣的感覺,我想巴黎人也是一樣的。
想認識更多法國文化的話,我在最近的線上課程裡面,除了入門法文之外,我還介紹了30堂文化課。其中一堂文化課,就是介紹關於法國人愛批評的民族文化。這堂文化課會分享如何學會法式批評(畢竟在法國批評也是有規矩,跟法國人還有其他法語區的人交流時,要注意不要踩雷,而我們確實也有很多點 😅),有興趣知道更多的朋友們可以到這個頁面看更多的資訊👇
https://jella.tw/native_languages/66
看完了Emily in Paris 的第一集,我看的還蠻開心的,畢竟是娛樂性的影集,失去了真實感也沒關係。很期待疫情結束後可以去巴黎玩,身為來自瑞士山區的鄉巴佬,一定會好好珍惜巴黎的美景,陶醉於巴黎的浪漫,絕對會忽略巴黎的比較不美的一面,畢竟每個地方都有自己認為不完美的一面,最後還是要看個人選擇,把眼界專注在哪個層面 😊
有人願意跟著我一起去體驗浪漫的巴黎嗎?😍🙋♂️
#杰宇的法文邂逅
#杰宇inParis
#法式批評
#文化分享
#線上課程
gorge衣服 在 Into the Wild 流浪記 Facebook 的最佳貼文
dates a girl who travels. 和一個旅行女孩約會吧。(請自行尋找相中亮點 XD) 【一舊雲 旅行者雜貨店】
Date a girl who travels. 和一個旅行女孩約會吧!
Date a girl who travels.
Date a girl who would rather save up for out of town trips or day trips than buy new shoes or clothes. She may not look like a fashion plate, but behind that tanned and freckled face from all the days out in the sun, lies a mind that can take you places and an open heart that will take you for what you are, not for what you can be.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。這個女孩,寧願把錢存下來當作旅行基金,也不會花在無謂的新衣服。她看起來可能不是個時尚辣妹,但在那張久經日曬的小麥色臉龐後,藏著一顆能帶你去任何地方,並且能欣賞你最真實個性的一顆心。
Date a girl who travels.
You’ll recognize her by the backpack she always carries. She won’t be carrying a dainty handbag; where will she put her travel journal, her pens, and the LED flashlight that’s always attached to her bag’s zipper? In a small purse, how can she bring the small coil of travel string, the wet tissues, the box of cracker, and the bottle of water she’s always ready with, just in case something happens and she can’t go home yet? Yes, a girl who travels knows that anytime, anything can happen and she just has to be prepared with it. Nothing takes her by surprise; she takes everything with equanimity, knowing that such things are always a part of life. She’s reliable and dependable, traits that she’s learned while on the road.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。你可以一眼就從那永不離身的背包認出她。並非一個無法裝載旅行日誌、筆、手電筒的精緻小提包,一個小包包怎麼能裝下旅行繩、溼毛巾、乾糧、和一瓶緊急備用的水呢?沒錯,一個旅行女孩知道隨時都有可能發生無法預料的事,所以她會永遠保持在準備好的狀態。沒有什麼事能嚇到她,她永遠可以泰然處之從容面對,知道這就是人生。她是值得信賴依靠的,這是她從旅途中學到的事。
You’ll also recognize a girl who travels by the fact that she’s always amazed at the world around her, no matter if she’s in her home town or in a place that’s totally new. She sees beauty all around her, not just the ones featured in travel guides or shown in postcards. A girl who travels has developed a deeper appreciation for life. She won’t judge you, or pressure you to do things you don’t want to do. She knows too much about the importance of identity and self-efficacy, and she will appreciate all the more if you won’t pretend to be who you’re not.
你也可以從旅行女孩那不管是在家鄉或是一個陌生城鎮,卻總能對她周遭事物充滿興趣的特質認出她。她可以發覺各式美麗事物,而不只是旅行指南或明信片上的熱門景點。一個旅行女孩會對生命由衷的欣賞,她不會武斷地評論你,也不會逼你做不情願的事。她清楚的知道自我肯定及認同的重要,如果你不矯揉造作,她對你加倍青睞。你可以對一個旅行女孩說謊,犯錯也沒有關係,你可以做最真實的自己。別擔心,她在旅途中碰過更糟的事,而且對變化莫測的人性也有深刻的認識。
Date a girl who travels, because when you’re with her, you’ll realize that even though she’s napped at a temple in Angkor Wat, went boating down the Mekong Delta, ran by the streets of Saigon, or went skinny-dipping in the caves in the Philippines , she still retains that humility that is the mark of a real traveler. She knows she’s been to a lot of places, but she’s humbled by the fact that the world is still a big place and she’s only seen a small part of it. Seeing this in her can make you feel all right with yourself too; there’s no need for you to do more, to be more. What you are is enough.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。和她在一起你會發現,無論她在吳哥窟小憩,在湄公河划船,在西貢的街上奔跑,或是在菲律賓的洞穴裸泳,她都謹記著「謙遜」才是旅人最重要的特質。她知道她去過很多地方,但她很謙虛地了解這世界很大,自己走過的地方只是一小部份。這項特質讓你也覺得很自在,你不需要虛假誇大,只需要做你自己。
When you meet a girl who travels, ask her where she’s been and what she’s going to do next. She will appreciate your interest, and if you’re lucky, she may even invite you to join her. When she does, do. Nothing bonds people better than traveling. On your trips, you will both see each other’s best and worst characteristics, and you can then decide whether she’s worth fighting for.
當你認識一個旅行女孩,問問她去過哪裡、下一個旅行地點是哪裡,她會很欣賞你的用心。夠幸運的話,說不定她還會約你結伴同行。如果她開口,就跟她一起去吧。沒有一件事能比旅行更能拉近人與人之間的關係,在旅程中,你們會發現彼此的優點和缺點,你也可以因此決定她是不是個值得的對象。
It’s easy enough to date a girl who travels. She won’t want expensive gifts; you can buy her (or both of you) cheap tickets to Thailand for the weekend, and she’ll be more than happy to take you to the longest wooden bridge in the country. You don’t even have to go overseas; you can take her out on day trips, caving or hiking, or treat her to a full body massage.
You can also buy her the little things that she keeps forgetting to buy for herself; that carabiner that will attach her backpack to her seat so that she will feel easier about sleeping on her bus trip, or a backpack cover, a small alarm clock, a money belt, or maybe another sarong that will replace the one she lost in China.
和一個旅行女孩約會很簡單。她不渴求昂貴的禮物,你可以買張飛往泰國渡週末的廉價機票給她或是來一趟雙人之旅,她會帶你去看世界上最長的木橋;你們甚至不用出國,你可以帶她去個洞穴探險或爬山的一日小旅行,或是讓她享受一套全身按摩。你也可以送她一些她總是忘記買的小東西。那條能綁住她的背包和座椅的鍊條,讓她能在巴士旅途中睡個好覺;一個背包套、小鬧鐘、可以藏錢的腰帶、或是一條新沙龍來代替她在中國遺失那條。
She won’t mind if you get lost on your way to a date. She knows that oftentimes, the journey is more important than the destination. She will help you see the lighter side of things. She’ll walk along with you, not behind you, pointing out the interesting bits of things you’ll see on the way. Before long, you’ll realize that yes, the journey has been more memorable than the destination that you’ve planned to take her to.
一個旅行女孩不介意你約會時迷路,她知道多數時候旅行的過程比結果更重要。她會讓看到事情的光明面,走在你身旁而不是你後方,為你指出一路上將看到的趣事。不用多久你就會真的了解,和她一起尋找的過程其實比你要帶她去的目的地更讓你記憶深刻。
Is a girl who travels worth it? Yes, she is. So when you find her, keep her. Don’t lose her with your insecurities and doubts. Because when she says she loves you, she really does. After all, she’s seen so many things, met so many people, and if she had chosen you, better grab that opportunity and thank the gods that you were lucky enough she’s chosen you and not that bloke she met while watching the sun rise in Angkor Wat, or while whitewater rafting in the Padas Gorge in Sabah. If she says she loves you, she must have seen something in you, something that can always call her back from her travels, something that can anchor her to the world in the way that she wants to after weeks and months of being on the road.
一個旅行女孩值得你追求嗎?是的,她值得。所以當你碰上她時,請好好珍惜她。不要因為你的不安全感或懷疑而放手,因為當她說她愛你,那絕對千真萬確。畢竟她看過那麼多各式事物,認識了那麼多不同的人;如果她選擇了你,請好好把握這個機會,並感謝老天她選擇的是你,而不是那個她在吳哥窟並肩看夕陽的男孩,或她在沙巴巴達士泛舟的同伴。如果她說她愛你,表示她一定有發現你的某些特別之處;一些能讓她回憶起過去旅行的小細節,一個能讓她在四處漂蕩好幾個月後可以停泊的港灣。
Date a girl who travels. Make her feel safe, warm, and secure. Make her believe that no matter where she goes, and however long she’s gone, you’ll always be there for her, the one that she can call home.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。給她安心和溫暖,讓她相信無論她去到哪裡,或是離開了多久,你都會在那個她能當作「家」的地方等待她。
Find a girl who travels. Date her, love her, and marry her, and your world will never be the same again.
找一個旅行女孩,和她約會,真愛她,讓她成為你的妻子。你的世界,將會因此而不同。
《《中文版譯自 Reddy Ting Ho。原文載自 Date A Girl Who Travels.》》
gorge衣服 在 林輝:旅遊寫作人 Facebook 的最佳解答
和一個旅行女孩約會吧!
Date a girl who travels. 和一個旅行女孩約會吧!
Date a girl who travels.
Date a girl who would rather save up for out of town trips or day trips than buy new shoes or clothes. She may not look like a fashion plate, but behind that tanned and freckled face from all the days out in the sun, lies a mind that can take you places and an open heart that will take you for what you are, not for what you can be.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。這個女孩,寧願把錢存下來當作旅行基金,也不會花在無謂的新衣服。她看起來可能不是個時尚辣妹,但在那張久經日曬的小麥色臉龐後,藏著一顆能帶你去任何地方,並且能欣賞你最真實個性的一顆心。
Date a girl who travels.
You’ll recognize her by the backpack she always carries. She won’t be carrying a dainty handbag; where will she put her travel journal, her pens, and the LED flashlight that’s always attached to her bag’s zipper? In a small purse, how can she bring the small coil of travel string, the wet tissues, the box of cracker, and the bottle of water she’s always ready with, just in case something happens and she can’t go home yet? Yes, a girl who travels knows that anytime, anything can happen and she just has to be prepared with it. Nothing takes her by surprise; she takes everything with equanimity, knowing that such things are always a part of life. She’s reliable and dependable, traits that she’s learned while on the road.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。你可以一眼就從那永不離身的背包認出她。並非一個無法裝載旅行日誌、筆、手電筒的精緻小提包,一個小包包怎麼能裝下旅行繩、溼毛巾、乾糧、和一瓶緊急備用的水呢?沒錯,一個旅行女孩知道隨時都有可能發生無法預料的事,所以她會永遠保持在準備好的狀態。沒有什麼事能嚇到她,她永遠可以泰然處之從容面對,知道這就是人生。她是值得信賴依靠的,這是她從旅途中學到的事。
You’ll also recognize a girl who travels by the fact that she’s always amazed at the world around her, no matter if she’s in her home town or in a place that’s totally new. She sees beauty all around her, not just the ones featured in travel guides or shown in postcards. A girl who travels has developed a deeper appreciation for life. She won’t judge you, or pressure you to do things you don’t want to do. She knows too much about the importance of identity and self-efficacy, and she will appreciate all the more if you won’t pretend to be who you’re not.
你也可以從旅行女孩那不管是在家鄉或是一個陌生城鎮,卻總能對她周遭事物充滿興趣的特質認出她。她可以發覺各式美麗事物,而不只是旅行指南或明信片上的熱門景點。一個旅行女孩會對生命由衷的欣賞,她不會武斷地評論你,也不會逼你做不情願的事。她清楚的知道自我肯定及認同的重要,如果你不矯揉造作,她對你加倍青睞。你可以對一個旅行女孩說謊,犯錯也沒有關係,你可以做最真實的自己。別擔心,她在旅途中碰過更糟的事,而且對變化莫測的人性也有深刻的認識。
Date a girl who travels, because when you’re with her, you’ll realize that even though she’s napped at a temple in Angkor Wat, went boating down the Mekong Delta, ran by the streets of Saigon, or went skinny-dipping in the caves in the Philippines , she still retains that humility that is the mark of a real traveler. She knows she’s been to a lot of places, but she’s humbled by the fact that the world is still a big place and she’s only seen a small part of it. Seeing this in her can make you feel all right with yourself too; there’s no need for you to do more, to be more. What you are is enough.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。和她在一起你會發現,無論她在吳哥窟小憩,在湄公河划船,在西貢的街上奔跑,或是在菲律賓的洞穴裸泳,她都謹記著「謙遜」才是旅人最重要的特質。她知道她去過很多地方,但她很謙虛地了解這世界很大,自己走過的地方只是一小部份。這項特質讓你也覺得很自在,你不需要虛假誇大,只需要做你自己。
When you meet a girl who travels, ask her where she’s been and what she’s going to do next. She will appreciate your interest, and if you’re lucky, she may even invite you to join her. When she does, do. Nothing bonds people better than traveling. On your trips, you will both see each other’s best and worst characteristics, and you can then decide whether she’s worth fighting for.
當你認識一個旅行女孩,問問她去過哪裡、下一個旅行地點是哪裡,她會很欣賞你的用心。夠幸運的話,說不定她還會約你結伴同行。如果她開口,就跟她一起去吧。沒有一件事能比旅行更能拉近人與人之間的關係,在旅程中,你們會發現彼此的優點和缺點,你也可以因此決定她是不是個值得的對象。
It’s easy enough to date a girl who travels. She won’t want expensive gifts; you can buy her (or both of you) cheap tickets to Thailand for the weekend, and she’ll be more than happy to take you to the longest wooden bridge in the country. You don’t even have to go overseas; you can take her out on day trips, caving or hiking, or treat her to a full body massage.
You can also buy her the little things that she keeps forgetting to buy for herself; that carabiner that will attach her backpack to her seat so that she will feel easier about sleeping on her bus trip, or a backpack cover, a small alarm clock, a money belt, or maybe another sarong that will replace the one she lost in China.
和一個旅行女孩約會很簡單。她不渴求昂貴的禮物,你可以買張飛往泰國渡週末的廉價機票給她或是來一趟雙人之旅,她會帶你去看世界上最長的木橋;你們甚至不用出國,你可以帶她去個洞穴探險或爬山的一日小旅行,或是讓她享受一套全身按摩。你也可以送她一些她總是忘記買的小東西。那條能綁住她的背包和座椅的鍊條,讓她能在巴士旅途中睡個好覺;一個背包套、小鬧鐘、可以藏錢的腰帶、或是一條新沙龍來代替她在中國遺失那條。
She won’t mind if you get lost on your way to a date. She knows that oftentimes, the journey is more important than the destination. She will help you see the lighter side of things. She’ll walk along with you, not behind you, pointing out the interesting bits of things you’ll see on the way. Before long, you’ll realize that yes, the journey has been more memorable than the destination that you’ve planned to take her to.
一個旅行女孩不介意你約會時迷路,她知道多數時候旅行的過程比結果更重要。她會讓看到事情的光明面,走在你身旁而不是你後方,為你指出一路上將看到的趣事。不用多久你就會真的了解,和她一起尋找的過程其實比你要帶她去的目的地更讓你記憶深刻。
Is a girl who travels worth it? Yes, she is. So when you find her, keep her. Don’t lose her with your insecurities and doubts. Because when she says she loves you, she really does. After all, she’s seen so many things, met so many people, and if she had chosen you, better grab that opportunity and thank the gods that you were lucky enough she’s chosen you and not that bloke she met while watching the sun rise in Angkor Wat, or while whitewater rafting in the Padas Gorge in Sabah. If she says she loves you, she must have seen something in you, something that can always call her back from her travels, something that can anchor her to the world in the way that she wants to after weeks and months of being on the road.
一個旅行女孩值得你追求嗎?是的,她值得。所以當你碰上她時,請好好珍惜她。不要因為你的不安全感或懷疑而放手,因為當她說她愛你,那絕對千真萬確。畢竟她看過那麼多各式事物,認識了那麼多不同的人;如果她選擇了你,請好好把握這個機會,並感謝老天她選擇的是你,而不是那個她在吳哥窟並肩看夕陽的男孩,或她在沙巴巴達士泛舟的同伴。如果她說她愛你,表示她一定有發現你的某些特別之處;一些能讓她回憶起過去旅行的小細節,一個能讓她在四處漂蕩好幾個月後可以停泊的港灣。
Date a girl who travels. Make her feel safe, warm, and secure. Make her believe that no matter where she goes, and however long she’s gone, you’ll always be there for her, the one that she can call home.
和一個旅行女孩約會吧。給她安心和溫暖,讓她相信無論她去到哪裡,或是離開了多久,你都會在那個她能當作「家」的地方等待她。
Find a girl who travels. Date her, love her, and marry her, and your world will never be the same again.
找一個旅行女孩,和她約會,真愛她,讓她成為你的妻子。你的世界,將會因此而不同。
《《中文版譯自 Reddy Ting Ho。原文載自 Date A Girl Who Travels.》》